Effects of inclined web slope on flutter performance of flat box girders and their quantification
LI Zhiguo1, WANG Qi1,2, LIAO Haili1, WEI Yifeng3
1. Research Center for Wind Engineering, Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu 610031, China；
2. Key Lab for Wind Resistance Technology of Bridges in Transportation Industry, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China;
3. Zhejiang Provincial Institute of Communications Planning, Design & Research，Hangzhou 310006, China
Influences of inclined web slope on flutter performance of flat box girders and their quantification were studied. Two sets of sectional models with fixed width and height, and different slopes of inclined web were designed and fabricated, dynamic parameters of the detecting system were kept unchanging, and flutter performances of different models were obtained with wind tunnel tests. The results showed that when the ratio of width to height for flat box girders is 11, effects of inclined web slope on the flutter critical wind speed are significant under the condition of 5 wind attack angle, but they are not obvious under the condition of 0 wind attack angle; when the ratio of width to height is 7, effects of inclined web slope on flutter are not obvious under either 5 wind attack angle or 0 one; changes of inclined web slope make flutter coupled derivative H3* and flutter direct derivative A2* vary significantly to cause greater variation of flutter critical wind speed. Finally, according test data and calculating results, adopting the flutter factor in the analytical calculation formula for the flutter critical wind speed, effects of wind attack angle inclined web slope on flat box girders’ flutter were quantified. Flutter factors under different conditions were deduced. It was shown that compared with the single reduced factor in the current flutter calculation code, conditioned flutter factors can be used to accurately calculate the flutter critical wind speed for flat box girders. The results provided a reference for effectively improving the aerodynamic layout of flat box girders.
李志国1，王骑1,2，廖海黎1，魏益峰3. 斜腹板倾角对扁平箱梁颤振性能影响及量化研究[J]. 振动与冲击, 2018, 37(9): 17-24.
LI Zhiguo1, WANG Qi1,2, LIAO Haili1, WEI Yifeng3. Effects of inclined web slope on flutter performance of flat box girders and their quantification. JOURNAL OF VIBRATION AND SHOCK, 2018, 37(9): 17-24.
[1] [1] LARSEN A. Aerodynamic aspects of the final design of the 1624m suspension bridge across the Great Belt [J]. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, 1993, 48(2-3): 261-285
[2] MIYATA T. Historical view of long-span bridge aerodynamics[J].Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, 2003,91(12-15): 1393–1410
[3] LUCA B, Giuseppe M. Importance of Deck Details in Bridge Aerodynamics[J]. Structural EngineeringInternational, 2002, 12( 4): 289-294
[4] WILDE K, Omenzetter P, Fujino Y. Suppression of bridge flutter by active deck-flaps control system[J], J. Eng. Mech. 2001,127 (1): 80–89.
[5] YANG Yongxin, GE Yaojun. Some Practices on Aerodynamic Flutter Control for Long-SpanCableSupported Bridges[C]. The 4th International Conference on AWAS’08, Jeju, Korea, 2008.8：1474~1485
[6] 鲜荣, 廖海黎. 封闭式扁平钢箱梁颤振稳定性气动优化措施风洞试验研究[J]，世界桥梁，2008, 3: 44-47
Xian Rong, Liao Haili. Wind Tunnel Test Study of Aerodynamic Optimization Measures for Flutter Stability of Closed Flat Steel Box Girder[J] .World Bridges, 2008, 3:44-47
[7] 朱乐东,张宏杰, 胡晓红.1400m 跨径钢箱梁斜拉桥方案颤振控制气动措施试验研究[J] .桥梁建设, 2011,2: 9-12
Zhu Ledong, Zhang Hongjie, Hu Xiaohong. Test Study of Aerodynamic Measures for Flutter Control of a Proposed 1 400-m Span Steel Box Deck Cable-Stayed Bridge[J] . Bridge Construction, 2011, 2: 9-12
[8] 曹丰产.桥梁断面中间开槽对颤振稳定性的影响[J].同济大学学报, 2002，30(5):551 -556.
CaoFengchan.Influence of Central Slot on Bridge Box Girder's Flutter Instability[J].Journal of Tongji University, 2002，30(5):551-556. In Chinese
[9] 杨詠昕, 葛耀君, 项海帆.中央稳定板颤振控制效果和机理研究[ J] .同济大学学报, 2007 , 35(2):149-155 .
YangYongxin , GE Yaojun , XIANG Haifan. 2007. Flutter Controlling Effect and Mechanism of Central Stabilizer[J].Journal of Tongji University, 2007, 35(2):149 -155.In Chinese
[10] 王骑,廖海黎, 李明水等.流线型箱梁气动外形对桥梁颤振和涡振的影响[J],公路交通科技，2012. 29(8)：44-50
Wang Qi, Liao Haili, Li Mingshui, et al. Influence of Aerodynamic Shape of Streamline Box Girder on Bridge Flutter and Vortex-induced Vibration[J],Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development，2012, 29(8)：44-50
[11] 于舰涵.斜腹板倾角对桥梁气动稳定性影响的数值模拟研究[D], 四川成都：西南交通大学硕士学位论文, 2014.
Yu Jianhan. Study on Numeric Simulation of influence of inclined webs on flutter instability of long-span bridges [D]. Chengdu: Southwest Jiaotong University，2014
[12] 张建,郑史雄,唐煜,王骑.基于节段模型试验的悬索桥涡振性能优化研究[J]，实验流体力学,2015, 29(2):48-54
Zhang Jian, Zheng Shixiong, Tang Yu, Wang Qi. Research on optimizing vortex-induced vibration performance for suspension bridge based on section model test [J]. Journal of Experiments in Fluid Mechanics, 2015.29(2):48-54
[13] LARSEN A, SAVAGE M,et al. Investigation of vortex response of a twin box bridge section at high and low Reynolds numbers[J], Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, 2008,96(6-7):934–944
[14] GE Yaojun, YANGYongxin, et al. VIV Sectional Model Testing and Field Measurement ofXihoumen Suspension Bridge with Twin Box Girder[C]. In: Proc. ICWE-13, Amsterdam, Netherland, 2011.7
[15] DIANA G,RESTA G, ZASSO A et al. Forced motion and free motion aeroelastic tests on anew concept dynamometric section model of the Messina suspension bridge[J]. J. Wind Eng.Ind.Aerodyn,2004, 92(6): 441-462
[16] DIANA, G., BELLOLIi, M., ROCCHI, D.. On the vortex shedding forcing on suspension bridge deck[J]. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics,2006,94(5):341–363.
[17] 王骑,林道锦,廖海黎,孙延国．分体式钢箱梁涡激振动特性及制振措施风洞试验研究[J],公路,2013,7:294-299
Wang Qi, Lin Daojin, Liao Haili, et al. Test study on vortex-induced vibration of twin-box girder and the mitigations[J],Highway,2013,7:294-299
[18] LARSEN A, WALL A. (2012), Shaping of bridge box girders to avoid vortex shedding response. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, 104-106, 159-165
[19] Chen, X. Improved Understanding of Bimodal Coupled Bridge Flutter Based on Closed-Form Solutions [J]. Journal of Structural Engineering, 2007.133(1): 22-31
[20] Matsumoto M, Kobayashi K, Niihara Y, et al. Flutter mechanism and its stabilization of bluff bodies[C]. Proc. 9th Inter. Conf. on Wind Eng. 1995. New Delhi, India.
[21] 杨詠昕.大跨度桥梁二维颤振机理及其应用研究[D]. 上海：同济大学博士学位论文. 2002
Yang Yongxin.Two-Dimensional Flutter Mechanism and Its Application for Long-Span Bridges[D].Shanghai:Tongji University，2002.
