A study on drilling breakage and rock breaking mechanism by using separated impact-scraping and cutting compound bit
CAI Can1,2,3, TAN Zhengbo1, XUAN Lingchao4,YANG Yingxin1,2,3, REN Haitao1,2, PU Zhicheng1, ZHANG Pei1, XIE Song1
1. Rock Breaking and Drill Bit Institute，School of Mechanical Engineering, Southwest Petroleum University,Chengdu 610500, China;
2. Rock Breaking and Drill Bit Institute，National Engineering Laboratory of Oil and Gas Drilling Technology, Southwest Petroleum University,Chengdu 610500, China;
3. The State Key Laboratory of Oil and Gas Reservoir Geology and Exploitation, Southwest Petroleum University,Chengdu 610500, China;
4.SINOPEC Research Institute of Petroleum Engineering, Beijing 100101, China
Abstract：With the continuous deepening of oil and gas exploration and development, the stick-slip, rebound and shock problems of traditional PDC bits in deep formations have become more and more prominent. Therefore, a new type of impact-scraping composite PDC bit has been proposed. Based on the working principle of the drill bit, experiments and numerical simulations of unit tooth impact, unit tooth cutting, and impact-scraping composite rock breaking were carried out. The results show that the impact pits generated by the impact tooth impacting on the rock reduce the strength of the rock near the impact pit, reduce the cutting force required by the cutting teeth, form larger cutting debris, and affect the stress distribution near the impact pit. At the same time, based on the orthogonal experiment, the sensitivity of impact parameters and cutting parameters was analyzed, and the influence of various factors on the impact-scraping composite rock breaking was explored. The results showed that the most influential factors were impact position, cutting speed, and impact tooth. Type and depth of cut. A full-size drill bit was used to compare and analyze the bottom hole morphology of the conventional PDC drill bit and the composite drill bit, and it was found that the composite drill bit had a larger bottom hole fracture volume. The research content has important reference value for the development and application of a new type of impact-scraping composite PDC bit.
Key words: impacting; rock breaking mechanism; impact-cutting compound rock breaking; numerical Simulation
蔡灿1,2,3，谭政博1，玄令超4，杨迎新1,2,3，任海涛1,2，蒲治成1，张沛1，谢松1. 分离式冲击-刮切复合钻头破岩机理及钻进破岩研究[J]. 振动与冲击, 2022, 41(16): 232-241.
CAI Can1,2,3, TAN Zhengbo1, XUAN Lingchao4,YANG Yingxin1,2,3, REN Haitao1,2, PU Zhicheng1, ZHANG Pei1, XIE Song1. A study on drilling breakage and rock breaking mechanism by using separated impact-scraping and cutting compound bit. JOURNAL OF VIBRATION AND SHOCK, 2022, 41(16): 232-241.
[1] United Diamond Ltd. Rotational Impact Drill Assembly[P].USA:US6742609B2,2004-6-1.
[2] Scott W. Powell, Ertai Hu, Greatwall Drilling CompanyHydraulic Percussion Drilling System with PDC Bit.J.Society of Petroleum Engineers[C]. SPE.196809. January 2015.
[3] 玄令超，管志川，呼怀刚，李敬皎.旋转冲击破岩实验装置的设计与应用[J].石油钻采工艺.2016.38(1).48-52.
XUAN Lingchao, GUAN Zhichuan, HU Huaigang, LI Jingjiao. Design and application of experimental apparatus for rock breaking by rotary percussion[J]. Oil Drilling & Production Technology. 2016.38(1).48-52.
[4] 李显义.库车坳陷岩石抗钻特性及扭转冲击破岩机理研究[D].东北石油大学,2017.
LI Xianyi. Research on Rock Drilling Resistance and Torsional Impact Rock Breaking Mechanism in Kuqa Depression[D]. Northeast Petroleum University, 2017
[5] Mu Z , Li G , Huang Z , et al. Research and Field Application of the Axial-Torsional Coupled Percussion Drilling Technology[J]. Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 2019, 142(3):1-18.
[6] 贾红军,王攀,冯伟雄,张俊杰,邱晓宁.深井硬岩地层钻井高频低幅扭转振荡耦合冲击器研制与应用[J].特种油气藏,2018,25(04):158-163.
JIA Hongjun, WANG Pan, FENG Weixiong, ZHANG Junjie, QIU Xiaoning. Development and Application of High-frequency Low-torque Impactor With Torsion-oscillation Coupling for Drilling of Deep and Hard Formations[J]. Special Oil & Gas Reservoirs, 2018,25(04):158-163.
[7] 刘宇. 机械式冲击器动力分析及辅助破岩仿真[D].长江大学,2020.
LIU Yu. Dynamic Analysis of Mechanical Impactor and Auxiliary Rock Breaking Simulation[D]. Yangtze University, 2020.
[8] 柳贡慧，李玉梅，李军，查春青，张涛，霍明明.复合冲击破岩钻井新技术[J].石油钻探技术.44(5).10-15.
LIU Gonghui, LI Yumei, LI Jun, ZHA Chunqing, ZHANG Tao, HUO Mingming. New Technology with Composite Percussion Drilling and Rock Breaking[J]. Petroleum Drilling Techniques. 44(5).10-15.
[9] 蔡灿,伍开松,廉栋,袁晓红.单齿冲击作用下破岩机制分析[J].岩土力学，2015,36(06):1659-1666+1675.
CAI Can, WU Kaisong, LIAN Dong, YUAN Xiaohong. Study of rock-breaking mechanism under single-tooth impact[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics, 2015,36(06):1659-1666+1675.
[10] 李思琪，李伟，闫铁，高晗，毕福庆，马红滨.复合载荷作用下钻头冲击破岩机理研究及现场应用[J].振动与冲击.2017,36(16).51-55.
LI Siqi, LI Wei, YAN Tie, GAO Han, BI Fuqing, MA Hongbin. A study on the rock breaking mechanism of drill bits under combined loads and field applications[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock. 2017,36(16).51-55.
[11] 祝效华,刘伟吉.旋冲钻井技术的破岩及提速机理[J].石油学报,2018,39(02):216-222.
ZHU Xiaohua, LIU Weiji. Rock breaking and ROP rising mechanism of rotary-percussive drilling technology[J]. Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2018,39(02):216-222.
[12] 刘书斌,倪红坚,王勇,张恒.多维冲击提高PDC钻头破岩效率的机理研究[J].振动与冲击,2021,40(02):258-264+278.
LIU Shubin, NI Hongjian, WANG Yong, ZHANG Heng. Mechanism of multi-dimensional impact loads applied in increasing therock cutting efficiency of a PDC bit[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock, 2021,40(02):258-264+278.
[13] 李玮,纪照生,董智煜,李卓伦,李悦.基于重整化方法的冲击载荷下岩石振动分析[J].振动与冲击,2016,35(16):49-54.
LI Wei, JI Zhaosheng, DONG Zhiyu, LI Zhuolun, LI Yue. Vibration analysis of rock under impact loads based on the renormalization method[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock, 2016,35(16):49-54.
[14] 方金. 钻进冲击载荷作用下软岩破碎规律的试验研究[D].西安科技大学,2020.
FANG Jin. Experimental Research on the Fragmentation Law of Soft Rock under Drilling Impact Load[D]. Xi'an University of Science and Technology,2020.
[15] 杨迎新,陈炼,林敏,包泽军,陈世彬,石擎天.一种刮切-冲击复合式钻头[P]. 四川：CN102678055A,2012-09-19.
YANG Yingxin, CHEN Lian, LIN Min, BAO Zejun, CHEN Shibin, SHI Qingtian,. A kind of scraping-impact compound drill bit[P]. SI Chuan: CN102678055A,2012-09-19.
[16] 谢松,蔡灿,杨迎新,任海涛,李邦润,曹煜磊.一种可控电磁驱动式冲击-刮切复合钻头及方法[P].四川：CN111236848A, 2020-06-05.
XIE Song, CAI Can, YANG Yingxin, REN Haitao, LI Bangrun, CAO Yilei. Controllable electromagnetic drive type impact-scraping composite drill bit and method[P].SI Chuan: CN111236848A, 2020-06-05.
[17] 石志明. PDC齿切削载荷的测试与分析[D].西南石油大学,2006.
SHI Zhiming. Testing and analysis cutting force of PDC cutters [D]. Southwest Petroleum University, 2006
[18] Huang, Kuilin, et al. Study on rock breakage mechanism of PDC bit with rotating module. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 192 (2020): 107312.
[19] 吴泽兵,吕澜涛,王勇勇,潘玉杰,张帅.牙轮—PDC混合钻头的破岩特性及温度场变化[J].天然气工业,2020,40(03):99-106.
WU Zebin, LV lantao, WANG Yongyong, PAN Yujie, ZHANG Shuai. Rock-breaking characteristics and temperature field change of cone–PDC hybrid bits[J]. Natural Gas Industry, 2020, 40(03):99-106.
[20] Najjarpour, M., Jalalifar, H., Norouzi-Apourvari, S. A review on half a century of experience in rate of penetration management: Application of analytical, semi-analytical and empirical models. Advances in Geo-Energy Research, 2021, 5(3): 252-273, doi: 10.46690/ager.2021.03.03
[21] Shuaifeng Lv,Shengwei Wang,Rui Li,Guoqing Li,Ming Yuan,Jiacheng Wang.Prediction of coal structure using particle size characteristics of coalbed methane well cuttings[J] .International Journal of Mining Science and Technology,2019,29(02):209-216.
[22] Hamed Rafezi,Ferri Hassani.Drilling signals analysis for tricone bit condition monitoring[J] .International Journal of Mining Science and Technology,2021,31(02):187-195.
