单向双轴振动台与结构相互作用的影响及补偿

PDF(2869 KB)

振动与冲击 ›› 2021, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (10) : 140-149.

论文

王巨科1,2，李小军1,2，李芳芳3，李娜1，张斌1

作者信息 +

Effect and compensation of the interaction between a unidirectional twin-axis shaking table and the tested structure

WANG Juke1,2，LI Xiaojun1,2，LI Fangfang3，LI Na1，ZHANG Bin1

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

为研究单向双轴振动台与结构的相互作用，建立了振动台与结构的传递函数矩阵(TFM)，研究了结构与振动台的质量比，结构的阻尼比、频率，以及结构与振动台的转动惯量比对传递函数矩阵的影响。结果表明：质量比、阻尼比和频率产生的影响集中在结构自振频率及周围的频段，而转动惯量比产生的影响位于油注共振频率及周围的频段；在相互作用影响的频段范围内，振动台的控制性能出现了不同程度的下降。基于以上研究，提出了一种实时补偿的控制策略，采用所提出的控制策略后，相互作用在频域的影响被完全地补偿；时域随机波的波形相关系数提升37.90%，误差的均方根值下降72.56%，振动台的控制性能得到很大的提升。

Abstract

A transfer function matrix (TFM) from shaking table to structure was established to study the interaction effect between a unidirectional twin-axes shaking table and the tested structure.The effects of the mass ratio between the structure and shaking table, the damping ratio and frequency of the structure, and the moment of inertia ratio between the structure and shaking table on the TFM were investigated.The results show that the mass ratio, damping ratio, and frequency affect the TFM at the natural frequency of the structure and in its surrounding frequency band, while the moment of inertia ratio exerts influence on the TFM at the oil resonance frequency and in its surrounding frequency band.The control performance of the shaking table is reduced with some degree in the affected frequency range.Based on the above research, a real-time compensation control strategy was proposed.With the application of the proposed strategy, the interaction effect is completely compensated in frequency domain, the time waveform correlation coefficient of a random wave is improved by 37.90% and the root mean value of the error is reduced by 72.56% in time domain.The control performance of the shaking table is greatly improved.

导出引用

王巨科1,2，李小军1,2，李芳芳3，李娜1，张斌1. 单向双轴振动台与结构相互作用的影响及补偿[J]. 振动与冲击, 2021, 40(10): 140-149

WANG Juke1,2，LI Xiaojun1,2，LI Fangfang3，LI Na1，ZHANG Bin1. Effect and compensation of the interaction between a unidirectional twin-axis shaking table and the tested structure[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock, 2021, 40(10): 140-149

参考文献

［1］高春华，纪金豹，闫维明，等.地震模拟振动台技术在中国的发展［J］.土木工程学报, 2014,47(8): 9-19.
GAO Chunhua, JI Jinbao, YAN Weiming, et al.Developments of shaking table technology in China［J］.China Civil Engineering Journal, 2014,47(8): 9-19.

［2］LI X J, WANG J K, LI F F, et al.Differential movement synchronous tracking control strategy of double-shaking table system loading with specimen［J］.Shock and Vibration, 2018,2018(8): 1-11.

［3］纪金豹，李芳芳，闫维明，等.分布式地震模拟振动台台阵控制器的硬件架构设计［J］.结构工程师, 2012,28(6): 102-107.
JI Jinbao, LI Fangfang, YAN Weiming, et al.Hardware architecture design of the distributed controller for the multiple shaking table array［J］.Structural Engineers, 2012,28(6): 102-107.

［4］纪金豹，李晓亮，闫维明，等.九子台模拟地震振动台台阵系统及应用［J］.结构工程师, 2011,27(增刊1): 31-36.
JI Jinbao, LI Xiaoliang, YAN Weiming, et al.Research on the shaking table array and dynamic model test［J］.Structural Engineers, 2011,27(Sup 1): 31-36.

［5］KIM J W, XUAN D J, KIM Y B.Design of a forced control system for a dynamic road simulator using QFT［J］.International Journal of Automotive Technology, 2008,9(1): 37-43.

［6］CLAUDIO P.Vibration tests on the preloaded LARES satellite and separation system［J］.Aerospace Science and Technology, 2015,42(4): 470-476.

［7］刘天虬.基于多目标优化的多电机伺服系统的结构/控制一体化设计［D］.北京: 北京理工大学，2016.

［8］ZHAI J J, ZHAO G Z, SHANG L Y.Integrated design optimization of structural size and control system of piezoelectric curved shells with respect to sound radiation［J］.Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization, 2017,56(6): 1287-1304.

［9］ZHANG C Q, OU J P.Control strategies and experimental verifications of the electromagnetic mass damper system for structural vibration control［J］.Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration, 2008,7(2): 181-192.

［10］DYKE S J, SPENCER B F, QUAST P, et al.Role of control-structure interaction in protective system design［J］.Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 1995,121(2): 322-338.

［11］LIU Y L, ZUO L.A computation-efficient framework for the integrated design of structural and control systems［J］.Journal of Dynamics Systems, Measurement, and Control, 2016,138: 091001.

［12］曾添一,任雪梅.基于有限时间滤波控制的电机驱动系统结构/控制一体化设计［J］.工程科学学报, 2019,41(9): 1194-1200.
ZENG Tianyi, REN Xuemei.Plant/controller co-design of motor driving systems based on finite-time filtering control［J］.Chinese Journal of Engnieering, 2019,41(9): 1194-1200.

［13］GOFRON M, SHABANA A A.Control structure interaction in the nonlinear analysis of flexible mechanical systems［J］.Nonlinear Dynamics, 1993,4(2): 183-206.

［14］何建军，陈享姿.基于微遗传算法的压电智能板结构/控制一体化拓扑优化设计及拓扑图提取［J］.机械强度, 2016,38(4): 754-759.
HE Jianjun, CHEN Xiangzi.Integrated topology optimization of structure/control for piezoelectric smart plate and its topology extraction based on micro-genetic algorithm［J］.Journal of Mechanical Strength, 2016,38(4): 754-759.

［15］ALYAQOUT S F, PAPALAMBROS P Y, ULSOY A G.Combined robust design and robust control of an electric DC motor［J］.IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics, 2011,16(3): 574-582.

［16］阎绍泽，季林红，刘才山，等.柔性机械臂结构-控制耦合特征的实验研究［J］.机械科学与技术, 2000,5: 796-799.
YAN Shaoze, JI Linhong, LIU Caishan, et al.On the structure-control interaction of flexible manipulators［J］.Mechanical Science and Technology, 2000,5: 796-799.

［17］王海红,保宏.伺服系统的结构/控制一体化设计［J］.组合机床与自动化加工技术， 2013,3: 96-99.
WANG Haihong, BAO Hong.Integrated structure and control design of servo system［J］.Modular Machine Tool and Automatic Manufacturing Technique, 2013,3: 96-99.

［18］STEWART G M, LACKNER M A.The effect of actuator dynamics on active structural control of offshore wind turbines［J］.Engineering Structures, 2011,33(5): 1807-1816.

［19］陈朝骏，李祚华，滕军，等.考虑CSI效应的AMD控制系统构建及其时变时滞补偿［J］.振动工程学报, 2018,31(1): 20-29.
CHEN Chaojun, LI Zuohua, TENG Jun, et al.Establishment of AMD control system considering CSI effect and its time-varying delay compensation［J］.Journal of Vibration Engineering, 2011,31(1): 20-29.

［20］翟景娟.压电曲壳结构振动与声辐射主动控制和优化［D］.大连: 大连理工大学, 2018.

［21］王海红.雷达伺服系统的结构/控制一体化设计［D］.西安：西安电子科技大学，2008.

［22］FENG Z W, ZHANG Q B, TANG Q G, et al.Control-structure integrated multiobjective design for flexible spacecraft using MOEA/D［J］.Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization, 2014,50(2): 347-362.

［23］ZHANG C W, OU J P.Control structure interaction of electromagnetic mass damper system for structural vibration control［J］.Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 2008,134(5): 428-437.

［24］VENANZI I, IERIMONTI L, UBERTINI F.Effects of control-structure interaction in active mass driver systems with electric torsional servomotor for seismic applications［J］.Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2017,15(4): 1543-1557.

［25］BLONDET M, ESPARZA C.Analysis of shaking table-structure interaction effects during seismic simulation tests［J］.Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics, 1988,16(4): 473-490.

［26］李暄，田石柱.地震模拟试验中地震波再现精度的研究［J］.哈尔滨建筑工程学院学报, 1993,26(4): 110-115.
LI Xuan, TIAN Shizhu.Research on the reproductive accuracy of the earthquake wave in the earthquake simulating test［J］.Journal of Harbin Architecture and Civil Engineering Institute, 1993,26(4): 110-115.

［27］唐贞云，李振宝，周大兴，等.试件特性对地震模拟振动台控制性能影响研究(Ⅱ)—对地震记录再现精度的影实时补偿［J］.北京工业大学学报, 2010,36(9): 1199-1205.
TANG Zhenyun, LI Zhenbao, ZHOU Daxing, et al.The effects on the earthquake simulation caused by the characteristics of the specimen in the shaking table tests-part 2：the effects on the replaying precision of the recorded seismic waves and the real-time compensation［J］.Journal of Beijing University of Technology, 2010,36(9): 1199-1205.

［28］MAOULT A L, QUEVAL J C, BAIRRAO R.Dynamic interaction between the shaking table and the specimen during seismic tests［C］//Fardis M.Advances in Performance-Based Earthquake Engineering.Dordrecht: Springer, 2010.

［29］LI F F, LI X J, WANG J K.Effects of interaction between dual shaking tables and specimen and force feedback compensation control［J］.Shock and Vibration, 2018,2018(2): 1-12.

［30］李振宝，唐贞云，周大兴，等.试件特性对地震模拟振动台控制性能影响Ⅰ—对系统稳定性的影响［J］.北京工业大学学报, 2010,36(8): 1091-1098.
LI Zhenbao, TANG Zhenyun, ZHOU Daxing, et al.The effects on the earthquake simulation caused by the characteristics of the specimen in the shaking table tests-part 1: the effects on the stability of the system［J］.Journal of Beijing University of Technology, 2010,36(8): 1091-1098.

［31］CONTE J P, TROMBETTI L T.Linear dynamic modeling of a uniaxial servo-hydraulic shaking table system［J］.Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics, 2000,29(9): 1375-1404.

［32］TROMBETTI L T, CONTE J P.Shaking table dynamics: results from a test-analysis comparison study［J］.Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 2002,6(4): 513-551.

［33］FLETCHER J N.Global simulation: new technique for multi-axis test control［J］.Sound and Vibration, 1990,24(11): 26-33.

［34］TWITCHELL B S, SYMANS M D.Analytical modeling, system identification, and tracking performance of uniaxial seismic simulators［J］.Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 2003,129(12): 1485-1488.

［35］DOZONO Y, HORIUCHI T, KATSUMATA H, et al.Improvement of shaking-table control by real-time compensation of reaction force caused by a specimen (2nd report, verification with large shaking table)［J］.Transactions of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers, 2005,71(702): 413-418.

［36］SEKI K, IWASAKI M, HIRAI H.Reaction force compensation with frequency identifier in shaking table systems［C］//Proceeding of the 11th IEEE International Workshop on Advanced Motion Control.Nogaoka: IEEE, 2010.

［37］田磐，陈章位.基于弹性负载的地震模拟试验控制策［J］.振动与冲击, 2013,32(5): 26-30.
TIAN Pan, CHEN Zhangwei.Control strategy in earthquake simulation test based on elastic payload［J］.Journal of Vibration and Shock, 2013,32(5): 26-30.

［38］NAKATA N.Acceleration trajectory tracking control for earthquake simulators［J］.Engineering Structures, 2010,32(8): 2229-2236.

［39］PHILLIPS B M, WIERSCHEM N E, SPENCER B F.Model-based multi-metric control of uniaxial shake tables［J］.Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics, 2014,43(5): 681-699.

［40］黄浩华.地震模拟振动台的设计与应用技术［M］.北京: 地震出版社, 2008.